Collection Call Scripts That Get You Paid (While Maintaining Relationships)

Globally, it is taking companies longer to collect cash, with Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) rising by 5.7% over the past decade. This trend of worsening receivables highlights a critical challenge: automated emails and passive reminders are often not enough, especially for complex or sensitive accounts.

This is where a direct, human-centric approach makes a measurable impact. While technology provides powerful tools, the skill of the collections expert remains critical. According to a recent Harvard Business Review Analytic Services report, enabling collections specialists to have more empathetic and successful negotiations can lead to a 6% increase in recoveries. A well-timed phone call provides the platform for this human connection, allowing for the nuanced conversation needed to resolve complex issues and secure payment.

Yet most AR teams still avoid picking up the phone. The hesitation is understandable. Collection calls feel confrontational. There's anxiety about damaging customer relationships, uncertainty about what to say, and genuine discomfort around discussing money.

Here's what changes that dynamic: treating collection calls as problem-solving sessions. When you know what to say, when to say it, and how to structure the conversation, these calls become one of your most effective tools.

But first, let's understand why certain approaches work while others backfire.

The Psychology Behind Effective Collection Calls

Four psychological principles separate effective collection calls from ineffective ones:

The Reciprocity Principle: When you lead with helpfulness rather than demands, customers feel obligated to reciprocate. Starting a call with "I'm calling to see if there's anything blocking payment on our end" triggers a completely different response than "I'm calling because your payment is overdue.”

The Ownership Effect: People are more likely to follow through on commitments they verbally state. This is why the best collection calls end with the customer saying out loud when they'll pay, not just agreeing to your timeline.

The Peak-End Rule: People remember experiences based on their emotional peak and how they ended. Even if a collection call involves uncomfortable topics, closing on a positive, collaborative note shapes how the customer remembers the entire interaction.

Status and Face-Saving: In B2B contexts, your contact is often caught between you and their own internal approvers. Providing them with language they can use internally ("Our vendor is being very accommodating, but they do need payment by...") gives them tools to advocate for you without losing face.

Keep these principles in mind as we walk through the collection call framework. They'll show up in every step, from how you open the conversation to how you secure commitment.

The 6-Step Collection Call Framework

Here's a methodical approach to every collection call, regardless of the situation. Each step serves a specific psychological and practical purpose.

Step 1: Prepare With Context

Never make a collection call cold. Before picking up the phone, you need complete visibility into:

• Payment history: Have they paid late before? Are they usually prompt?

• Communication history: What have they already been sent? When was the last touchpoint?

• Account health: Are they a growing customer? Shrinking? What's their lifetime value?

• Invoice specifics: What's the amount? Any disputes on record? Are there related open invoices?

This preparation determines your tone and approach. A historically reliable customer who's 15 days late gets a different call than a chronic late payer at 60 days.

Step 2: Open With Warmth and Clarity

The first 15 seconds set the tone for everything that follows. Your goal is to be friendly but direct, concerned but not aggressive.

Start with:

• A genuine greeting (using their name)

• A clear reason for calling

• An assumption of partnership, not conflict

Example: "Hi Sarah, it's Ron from ABC Company. I'm calling about invoice #4782. I wanted to check in and see if there's anything on our side that's holding up payment."

Notice what this opening does: it's warm, it's specific, and it immediately positions you as someone solving a problem together rather than making a demand.

Step 3: Listen More Than You Talk

This is where most collection calls go wrong. There's a temptation to fill silence with justifications, explanations, or pressure. Resist it.

After your opening, ask an open-ended question and then be quiet:

• "Can you help me understand where things are on your end?”

• "What's the status of this invoice in your system?”

• "Is there anything preventing this from being processed?”

The information you gather here is gold. You might discover:

• The invoice was never received

• There's a dispute you weren't aware of

• Their AP process requires documentation you didn't provide

• They're waiting on a PO that hasn't been approved

• They're having cash flow issues themselves

You cannot solve a problem you don't understand. Listen first.

Step 4: Collaborate on Solutions

Based on what you learned, offer a path forward. This is where you shift from "here's what you owe" to "here's how we can resolve this together.”

For process issues: "I can resend that invoice with the updated PO number within the hour. Would that unblock things on your end?”

For approval bottlenecks: "If it helps, I can send you a summary email you can forward to your finance director with the key details highlighted.”

For cash flow issues: "I understand timing is tight right now. Can you make a partial payment this week, and we can work out a timeline for the remainder?”

The key is offering solutions that make it easier for them to pay you, not harder.

Step 5: Secure a Verbal Commitment

This is the moment that separates effective calls from time-wasting ones. You need a specific commitment, stated out loud by the customer.

Avoid vague endings like:

• "So you'll try to get this processed soon?”

• "Let me know when it's paid.”

• "Hopefully we'll see payment next week."

Instead, get specific:

• "So to confirm, you'll process the payment this Thursday, and I should see it hit our account by Monday. Is that right?”

• "Perfect, so you'll send that approval request today, and you expect to have payment out by the end of next week. Can I follow up with you on Friday to confirm it's gone through?”

When someone says a commitment out loud, they're significantly more likely to follow through.

Step 6: Document and Tag Your Team Immediately

The moment you hang up, document everything:

• What was discussed

• What was committed

• What you agreed to do

• When you'll follow up

If the situation requires input from other teams (sales, customer success, finance leadership), tag them immediately so they have full context.

Ready-to-Use Scripts for Common Scenarios

Here are word-for-word scripts for the situations you'll encounter most often. Each includes the psychology at play and a pro tip for execution.

Scenario 1: First Call for Recently Overdue Invoice (15-30 days)

The Script:

"Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] from [Company]. How are you doing?

I'm calling about invoice #[Number] for [Amount], which was due on [Date]. I wanted to reach out personally to make sure everything is in order on your end and see if there's anything we need to provide to help move this along.

[Pause for response]

[If they acknowledge and commit to payment:] That's great to hear. Just to confirm, you're expecting to process payment by [specific date]? Perfect. I'll make a note of that, and if for any reason something changes, just let me know. I'll also send you a confirmation email after this call with the payment details.

[If they indicate an issue:] I appreciate you letting me know. Let me see what we can do to help resolve this. [Offer specific solution based on their response.]

Thanks so much for taking the time to talk through this with me, [Name]. I really appreciate the partnership."

Scenario 2: Payment Commitment Was Broken

The Script:

"Hi [Name], it's [Your Name] from [Company].

I wanted to follow up on our conversation from [last week/date]. You'd mentioned that payment for invoice #[Number] would be processed by [date], but I'm not seeing it reflected in our account yet.

[Pause for response]

[Listen to their explanation without interrupting]

I understand these things happen. What I'd like to do is figure out a realistic timeline that works for your team. What's the soonest you can commit to having this processed?

[Get specific date]

Okay, so [date]. And just so I can set expectations on my end, is there anything that might prevent that from happening? Any approvals still pending or issues I should be aware of?

[Address any concerns]

Great. I'm going to note this as a firm commitment for [date], and I'll plan to check in with you on [day after] if I haven't seen payment come through. Does that work for you?

[Confirm]

Thanks for working through this with me, [Name]. I know things get busy on your end, and I really appreciate you being upfront about the situation."

Scenario 3: Significantly Overdue (90+ days)

The Script:

"Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] from [Company].

I'm calling about invoice #[Number] for [Amount], which is now [number] days past due. This has moved into a more urgent category on our end, and I need to understand what's happening so we can resolve it.

[Pause for response]

[If they provide a legitimate reason:]

I appreciate you explaining that. Here's the situation from my side: at this stage, I need to either see payment processed within [timeframe], or we'll need to set up a formal payment arrangement. Which of those works better for your situation?

[If they're evasive or non-committal:]

I understand this might not be the most comfortable conversation, but I do need a concrete resolution today. Without that, I'll have to escalate this to [your manager/their account manager/collections], which I'd prefer to avoid if we can work this out directly.

What I'm hearing is [summarize their explanation]. Based on that, here's what I'd like to propose: [offer payment plan or partial payment option].

If we can agree on that today, I can keep this from escalating and we can maintain the working relationship we've had. Does that work for you?

[Get verbal commitment to specific terms]

Okay, so we're agreed: [restate payment terms clearly]. I'm going to send you a confirmation email right after this call, and I'll follow up on [specific date] to confirm the first payment has been made. If something changes before then, I need you to contact me directly at [your email/number] so we can adjust the plan. Fair enough?

Thanks for working with me on this, [Name]. I know this isn't easy, but I appreciate you being willing to find a solution."

Scenario 4: Customer Claims They Never Received the Invoice

The Script:

"Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] from [Company].

I'm calling about invoice #[Number] for [Amount]. I wanted to check in because our records show it was sent on [date], but I want to make sure it actually made it to you.

[Pause for response]

[When they say they didn't receive it:]

No problem at all, these things happen. Let me get that over to you right away. What's the best email address for you, and is there anyone else who should be copied?

[Confirm email]

Perfect. I'm going to send that within the next [15 minutes/hour], and I'll include the original invoice date and the payment terms. Since this is already past due based on the original terms, when can I expect payment once you receive it?

[Get commitment]

Great. So I'll send the invoice to [email] right after we hang up, and you're committing to process payment by [date]. I'll make a note of that and follow up with you on [date] to confirm everything went through.

Is there anything else you need from me to ensure this doesn't get held up again?

Thanks so much for your time, [Name]."

Scenario 5: Customer Is Disputing the Invoice

The Script:

"Hi [Name], this is [Your Name] from [Company].

I'm calling about invoice #[Number]. I understand there's some question about the charges, and I wanted to talk through that with you directly so we can get this resolved quickly.

[Pause for response]

[Let them fully explain the dispute without interrupting]

Okay, I think I understand the issue. Let me make sure I have this right: [summarize their concern back to them].

[Confirm you understood correctly]

Here's what I'd like to do. For the portion that's undisputed, can we get that processed while we work through the [disputed amount]? That way we're making progress while we investigate.

[If they agree to partial payment:]

Perfect. So we'll process payment of [undisputed amount] by [date], and I'll work with our team on [the dispute] and get back to you by [specific date] with a resolution. Does that timeline work?

[If dispute seems legitimate:]

I'm going to open a case on this internally and get you an answer by [specific date]. In the meantime, can I ask what documentation would help resolve this on your end? Would you need [revised invoice/delivery confirmation/contract terms/etc.]?

[If dispute seems like a delay tactic:]

I want to make sure we resolve this fairly, but I also need to keep things moving. While we investigate, would you be open to processing payment into a holding status, or would a payment plan make more sense while we work through the details?

Thanks for walking me through this, [Name]. I'll get you an update by [date], and let's plan to connect again then to finalize everything."

Building a Collection Culture, Not Just Making Calls

Collection calls are a tactic, but the real transformation happens when you build a culture where payment conversations are normal, expected, and relationship-positive.

That means:

Starting payment conversations earlier. Don't wait until invoices are 60 days past due to pick up the phone. Call at 7 days for high-risk accounts, 15 days for standard accounts. The earlier you intervene, the easier the conversation.

Equipping your team with the right tools. Collection calls are significantly more effective when your AR team has complete context at their fingertips, including communication history, payment patterns, and the ability to offer solutions like payment plans in real-time.

Making it safe to have honest money conversations. The companies with the best collection performance are those where finance teams aren't afraid to have straightforward payment discussions. That safety comes from good scripts, clear processes, and leadership that supports assertive (not aggressive) collections.

Collection calls will never be the most glamorous part of accounts receivable. But when done well, they're some of the most valuable. Every conversation is a chance to strengthen a customer relationship, solve a real problem, and improve your cash position.

Ready to transform your collections process? Upflow gives your AR team everything they need to have confident, effective collection conversations. Make calls directly within the platform with full payment history and context at your fingertips, log promise-to-pay commitments in real-time, and keep your entire team aligned with seamless collaboration tools.

FAQs